We should start this post by explaining what the difference is between preaching and teaching. Preaching focuses on public proclamation and emotional urging to spark repentance or moral action, while teaching delivers systematic instruction to explain content and build knowledge. Although both may draw on the same foundational religious or moral material, preaching targets the heart and will, while teaching targets the mind.
The goal of teaching is to help individuals master a specific subject methodically, so the student can ultimately achieve the same level of knowledge as the teacher, or even surpass the instructor’s understanding of the topic. The master eventually transfers all the knowledge to the students. On the other hand, preaching does not aim toward building our intellect, increasing our knowledge, and exercising our use of reason, but rather the purpose of preaching is to move people to behave or act in a certain desired manner.
Emotional preaching produces immediate results. On the other hand, the teaching and possession of facts and knowledge alone do not generally cause people to act or make decisions, since we are driven by emotions. Preaching can thus be used to manipulate people, drive emotional responses, and motivate or justify harmful behaviors in the listeners; therefore, preaching, instead of teaching, is used to deliver fast, intended, or wanted outcomes.
Humans are created as emotional beings, but we should be strictly ruled by reason so as not to fall for theatrical performances, artificial tear-jerking, or underhanded psychological machinations. Because of our nature, politicians, publicity ads, and charismatic preachers can easily lead anyone into beliefs and convictions that are false, wrong, or misleading. However, the truth alone should be capable of moving our hearts. If it does not, then there is a problem.
Today, those who teach Christianity are usually called preachers. And increasingly there are more preachers than listeners and audiences. However, the founder of the Christian religion was a rabbi. The Hebrew word “rabbi” literally means teacher, not priest or preacher. Jesus was fundamentally known as a teacher, not as a preacher.
According to John 1:1 and Revelation 19:13, Jesus was also the Logos. Effective forms of communication include three persuasion modes: ethos, pathos, and logos. Ethos is an appeal based on the character and reputation of the message’s communicator. Pathos is an appeal based on emotion. Advertisements tend to be pathos-driven. Logos is an appeal based on the logic of the argument itself. When listening to a sermon, we can have faith in the person (ethos), faith in what the person is communicating to the emotional area of the mind (pathos), or assurance in the logic and reason of what the person is saying to the intellectual area of the mind (logos). Preaching is usually driven by pathos and ethos modes. Teaching is always driven by a logos mode of persuasion. The objective truth emphasizes the logos persuasion appeal, and Jesus was a teacher who persuaded us through a logos appeal only. Therefore, truth alone should be enough to make us behave and act as Christians. If it is not, the problem certainly is not the truth!
The original Christian Church associated Jesus with logic, truth, and reasoning from the mind of God (Logos in ancient Greek philosophy). The logos appeal can be associated with reason and common sense. But many of today’s Christians emphasize their own emotions and feelings (pathos appeal) or put their trust in certain people (ethos appeal) that they should not. Instead, today’s Christianity should emphasize using reason and the mind (only trusting in logos appeals).
The primitive (early New Testament) church did not even have preachers or priests either. This church featured a decentralized, shared, and unpaid leadership structure. Instead of having priests and pastors maintaining an active, salaried, structured, and hierarchical role in the church, combined with a mostly passive audience in the congregation or laity, as we find today in the modern church, the primitive church had active communities, meaning everyone was active, not only the leadership. The people were the church then.
If you read the New Testament, you can see that whole families were active in their faith. The Apostle Philip’s four daughters had the gift of prophecy (Acts 21:8), for instance. “Aquila…with his wife Priscilla” (Acts 18:2) is another example. God is our Father, so meeting in homes, calling others brother and sister, and maintaining a family atmosphere linked by their faith was the norm. Today, the building is the church.
The members of the original church were primarily witnesses, in addition to being believers, to a world that never heard about Jesus. That is not the case today. Many people around the world might not believe in Jesus or like him, but by now, basically everyone on this planet has heard the name of Jesus. So, instead of preaching, these people need to be taught who Jesus is. That …we do not do.
At that time, the only qualifications to hold office in the church, as described by Peter, were that they had to be men, they had to be of good report, and they had to be full of the Holy Ghost and wisdom. They just had to prove with their behavior that God was in their lives. In I Timothy 3:8-13, Paul explains in more detail the requirements. They must “be grave, not double-tongued, not given to much wine, not greedy of filthy lucre (money hungry).” They must “hold the faith in a pure conscience.” They must have a track record of consistent service and leadership in the church, or as Paul says, “let these ….first be proved; then let them use the office of a deacon.” Not only that, but they must have a stable home life: their wives must be believers, and they must rule their children and their home well.
These are common offices and jobs held during the times of the Apostles:
Apostles: Chosen witnesses and foundational figures (such as Peter, Paul, and John) tasked with launching the church, establishing core doctrine, and traveling broadly. Paul proudly mentioned that he worked for a living and was not salaried.
Prophets: Spirit-empowered speakers who delivered immediate, edifying, or predictive words from God to the body of believers.
Evangelists: Itinerant messengers and church-planters who traveled to unreached areas to share the gospel (such as Philip or Timothy).
Elders / Overseers / Pastors: The terms presbyteros (elder), episkopos (overseer/bishop), and poimen (pastor) were used interchangeably in the 1st century to describe the local leaders of a house church. They worked in a plurality to teach, shepherd, and govern the community. They usually were not salaried, but held jobs.
Deacons: From diakonos (servant), these individuals were appointed to manage practical, physical, and financial needs—such as distributing food, caring for widows, and supporting the elders’ spiritual work. They were active helpers.
As you can see, the original church of Jesus did not have use for preachers. It was not the same as today’s. A quick explanation for this difference is that many pagan customs were incorporated into Christian doctrine after the Roman Empire legalized Christianity, long after the Apostles and actual witnesses were gone. Syncretism is the formal name for this turn of events when Christian doctrine fused with existing pagan beliefs in the Roman Empire.
This evolution involved the blending of traditional Greco-Roman, Celtic, and Near Eastern pagan practices with emerging Christian traditions as the faith expanded and became institutionalized throughout the empire. The result was the Catholic Church and all its corruption. Although the Protestant Reformation did much to clean and improve the doctrine, it still left many pagan ideas in our belief system. However, you do not need to believe my narrative. If you start googling, seeking, and searching, you can learn exactly what happened.
